NCAA issues “Notice of Inquiry” to UNC-CH and tOSU Phone Records Show Link to UNC’s Baddour

UNC Scandal77

WRAL is reporting the following statement that was released today from UNC’s Athletic Director Dick Baddour:

Full story.

“The notice of inquiry is a formal notification from the NCAA that they have been reviewing our football program,” said UNC Director of Athletics Dick Baddour. “We have been working with the NCAA and cooperating with them on this investigation. We are committed to the process and will continue to cooperate.”

WRAL News and others have asked for documents related to the NCAA and an internal investigation of the UNC football team, maintaining that they are public records. University officials have denied access to the records, citing student privacy protection laws.

NCAA letter.

 
Getting beyond the continued and quite silly “Review v. Investigation” semantics still hilariously being perpetuated by the UNC powers that be, the “Notice of Inquiry” is hardly news to anyone with a pulse living within 500 miles of the Triangle. UNC has been under investigation for over a year, so the letter being mentioned herein is a mere formality. At least Dick got that much right.

What is more interesting is the second paragraph. The release of phone records and parking ticket information formally requested by WRAL, The Daily Tarheel, and other local media members via a Freedom of Information Act request is still being adamantly resisted and legally stonewalled by UNC and the University’s counsel.

UNC has already been ordered to hand over the information by a Wake County Superior Court Judge, but UNC and lawyers have requested a stay of that order while the matter can be appealed. You can read more on the legal gerrymandering by visiting WRAL here.

Interestingly enough, UNC has already lost on almost this exact same issue (hiding behind FERPA to avoid releasing information wholly ancillary to the student’s school work or academic record) in Federal Court when dealing with a lawsuit involving a former female soccer player alleging bad acts against legendary coach Anson Dorrance. If you are unfamiliar, perhaps the most brief account of the situation can be found on Coach Dorrance’s Wikipedia page here. It’s Wikipedia, mind you, so take it for what it’s worth. If you’re legally inclined, or having serious insomnia issues and are looking for a late-night reading cure for the same, you can check out the following case: 340 F. Supp. 2d 679 (2004).

The precedent mentioned above was more thoroughly discussed in this SFN entry if you missed it:

Judge rules against UNC-CH in media’s lawsuit (updated with Thorp’s statements) (2nd update with legal analysis)

The question rages on: How on earth can the NCAA conduct much less conclude a thorough investigation without the phone records and parking tickets requested by local media outlets, including the Daily Tarheel ?

First, are there enough words to use to honor the backbone and overall integrity of the folks in charge of UNC’s school newspaper? Simply: No. Nice work, DTH, nice work. Something is clearly amiss when your own school newspaper turns on you regarding parking ticket information that is likely widely discussed by students all across campus. Phone records are pretty easily hidden, but fancy cars don’t go unseen.

I have to believe that the “new information” warned of in the official and confidential (hilarious!) “Letter of Inquiry” sent today is likely what lies in UNC’s pandora’s box to which the media has been judicially given the key but UNC’s attorneys still guard and appeal with all their mental might.

Some tiny insight into what might be hiding in that box was provided today from an unlikely source. Wait. Come to think of it, given the current events flying around college football over the last 12 months the source, and therein the connection, makes absolute sense.

Bryan Fischer of CBSSPORTS.COM tweeted a gem of a find today. Apparently Fischer took the reigns in sifting through what is likely piles and piles of phone records of Ohio State Athletic Department members, including Athletic Director Gene Smith, that were recently released by the Ohio State University pursuant to a Freedom of Information Act Request filed by the media seeking the same. What he found is puzzling a bit, but not really.

@BryanDFischer Bryan Fischer
Based on Ohio State’s phone records, once Gene Smith realized there was a problem, he called UNC AD Dick Baddour.
10 hours ago via TweetDeck

Joe Ovies reached out to Fischer via Twitter and at least thought the homework done was worthy of making this post on WRAL Sportsfan.

Ovies also tweeted that ABCers will dub this the “8th Prong.” While quite funny, the irony lies in the fact that this seemingly meaningless and very weird phone call could even be considered any prong over maybe the “2nd.” The investigation… review… has gotten that complex and encompassed several sports at UNC. The bizarro world that has become the UNC Football Scandal is without a doubt book-worthy. Let’s be honest here. People seldom read books about rule followers and clean living.

If UNC took all of these rule-breaking risks to become one of the “Big Boys” in college football, maybe they finally got their wish. Most coaches go to the likes of Urban Meyer to get consulted on his lethal offense. Many coaches reach out to other programs to learn about a scheme change that needs to be implemented in their own program. Players work out over the summer with kids from other programs to fuel new fire and a different perspective into their workouts.

Hilariously enough, that’s not how it goes for the Heels. It appears the “Big Boys” are indeed calling. But they are most likely doing so to yank a couple pages from UNC’s playbook on how to call a year-long NCAA Investigation a “review that will be over by Friday” with a straight face. The likes of Ohio State, currently mired in such scandal that legendary sweater-vest-wearing Coach Jim Tressell has left the program as has All-World junior quarterback Terrell Pryor in just the last week or so, are calling to learn how to deflect and defend what is clearly going to be a long, painful trip to NCAA violation hell and back.

This is simply hysterical. But as we catch our breath, let’s give credit where credit is due…

One thing the author group at SFN has always admired about UNC and their administration is that the folks in Chapel Hill are second to none when it comes to the shameless spin, manipulation of public perception, misleading branding (“The Carolina Way”), and their ability to do all of this for the sole purpose of turning attention away from their skirting of the rules. In comparison, if UNC’s media machine is a Masserati, we State folks are indeed still puttin’ down the old country road on Granddad’s rust-riddled tractor. So to that well-greased-sexy-beast of a UNC Media Machine, we raise a glass for what is so far a job extremely well done. Imitation is indeed the most sincere form of flattery.

Keep it up, gentlemen, it will all be over by Friday…

UNC Scandal

77 Responses to NCAA issues “Notice of Inquiry” to UNC-CH and tOSU Phone Records Show Link to UNC’s Baddour

  1. K_Wolf 06/07/2011 at 5:22 PM #

    Friday keeps getting closer. Sounds like less than six months away now. (Awesome pic of Mr 0-4)

  2. tuckerdorm1983 06/07/2011 at 5:34 PM #

    nothing to see her folks, move along. Move it, Move it, Move it and Nip it in the bud.

    B. Fife

  3. NCStatePride 06/07/2011 at 5:36 PM #

    It’s going to be a good week, guys.

  4. chriscgray 06/07/2011 at 6:03 PM #

    Every school says they comply with the NCAA. However if you lie, it is not in compliance with anything. I find it so hard to believe Butch or others did not know of any improper behavior. I think they should atleast lose scholarships, and depending upon NCAA findings maybe lose a chance for bowl season.

  5. tuckerdorm1983 06/07/2011 at 6:07 PM #

    at a minimum

  6. nav 06/07/2011 at 6:54 PM #

    If this was a classroom and I asked you guys how many felt deep down inside that UNC would get by with a slap on the wrist I bet most of you would raise their hands.

  7. Wolfy__79 06/07/2011 at 7:05 PM #

    nice pics and write up..

  8. BureauOfMines 06/07/2011 at 7:16 PM #

    “If this was a classroom and I asked you guys how many felt deep down inside that UNC would get by with a slap on the wrist I bet most of you would raise their hands.”

    If the end result was going to be much more than a slap on the wrist this mess would not have drug on for a year. It has the look and feel of a delay game. They were just hoping the whole thing would blow over.

  9. Old MacDonald 06/07/2011 at 7:26 PM #

    Haven’t they already gotten WAY more than a slap on the wrist, before the NCAA does anything?

  10. LRM 06/07/2011 at 7:38 PM #

    Wait, did Dickie B just call it an “investigation?” Sounds serious.

  11. Wolf74 06/07/2011 at 7:49 PM #

    Whatever punishment they get from the NCAA it won’t be enough. They have been cheating over there for years and years and not just in football. UNC-Cheats, to seem rather than to be.

  12. nav 06/07/2011 at 8:03 PM #

    “Haven’t they already gotten WAY more than a slap on the wrist, before the NCAA does anything?”

    Please explain. I assume you are talking about UNC choosing to sit their players last season. Their recruiting hasn’t suffered.

  13. blpack 06/07/2011 at 8:25 PM #

    This is the beginning of the end for Butch.

  14. cWOhLFrPAiCKs 06/07/2011 at 8:31 PM #

    ^That’s sad…I really enjoyed beating him!

  15. packplantpath 06/07/2011 at 8:42 PM #

    Unc has not been punished at all and don’t let them convince you that holding out players was their punishment. That was punishment for the players and it only affected the university by proxy. The players were punished for doing the violation . The university needs punishment for their own failures.

    I still will not be shocked if they get a very light punishment though.

  16. GAWolf 06/07/2011 at 9:06 PM #

    No, no. The players were held out because they school knew dang well there was fire near the smoke, and they didn’t want to willfully play kids who would literally burn their program to the ground.

    I agree, they’ve hardly been punished. If anything they’ve done everything they could to get kids who were in trouble back on the field as soon as possible. And they succeeded in several instances.

  17. The Grinch 06/07/2011 at 9:13 PM #

    maserati

  18. Old MacDonald 06/07/2011 at 9:41 PM #

    [quote]

    Please explain. I assume you are talking about UNC choosing to sit their players last season. Their recruiting hasn’t suffered.

    [/quote]

    I mean the hit they have taken in the press and the fact that they can no longer ever claim any high ground. I will take that any day over whatever bean-counting, ephemeral penalties the NCAA puts on them. Marv pulled the plug on “the Carolina Way” permanently.

  19. Hungwolf 06/07/2011 at 10:23 PM #

    NCAA letter to UNC-Cheat is copied to John Swofford. Nothing on ACC web site about the letter. Still nothing from the ACC office. Letter even references the NCAA, member schools, and conferences as enforcing rules of fair play.

    NOT in this case the ACC has turned a blind eye to its commissioner’s former employer and school. Swofford should be fired! He nailed FSU for resting some girls before ACC conference tournament, but has not a word to say about the biggest scandal in the conference since he became commiss. Shameless!

  20. GAWolf 06/07/2011 at 10:31 PM #

    ^Agree. That’s ridiculous. There has not been one peep from the Conference since this thing began, right? Please point me to one if I’m wrong.

    Certainly the NCAA will see this as a reality, right? Won’t the NCAA have to take the necessary action itself to get a fair and just result? This is why I’m still hopeful for something above a retroactive slap on the wrist.

    Someone at the NCAA should see that UNC gives its players the same privileges the Conference Commissioner gives his school.

  21. choppack1 06/07/2011 at 10:41 PM #

    There’s an old poker saying:

    Every game has a fish. Look around the table. if you don’t know who the fish is, it’s you.

    I think we’re the fish here. I don’t think much is going to happen.

    The NCAA slapped UConn on the wrist. Cam Newton led Auburn to a national championship in football.

    The local media hasn’t done diddly squat. Yes, they’ve requested records – but why in the hell not park a reporter outside of UNC’s football center to see what cars their players were driving?

    Don’t expect anything from the public records request or the NCAA.

  22. ryebread 06/07/2011 at 10:46 PM #

    Swofford is a complete joke.

    I fully expect UNC to get a slap on the wrist.

  23. TAEdisonHokie 06/07/2011 at 10:51 PM #

    Just in case anyone wants to know the exact procedure the NCAA follows during an investigation, here’s a good website to bookmark:

    What procedure does the NCAA follow in an investigation?
    http://www.wsfa.com/Global/story.asp?S=13481687

  24. GAWolf 06/07/2011 at 10:55 PM #

    Any chance the NCAA has ferreted out the parking of baseball players going by one particular MLB super agent? If they’ve found concerning connections of new players and maybe agents on the football front that have been rarely mentioned in common discussion, have they also finally put the screws to Fox and Co? Several baseball players have definitely left under weird circumstances since this whole racket started to come to light.

  25. GAWolf 06/07/2011 at 11:09 PM #

    Thanks TAE. That recap basically says this thing can go on ad nauseum for years…a la USC… So either Greg Barnes is talking out of his Hiney The Toothless One… Or he thinks he has some solid inside information that this Peter is indeed the beginning fnthe end. All signs point to the latter given IC’s constant misinformtion so far on the Review That Ends Friday.

    I personally expect nothing else from the NCAA for some time….at least six months. Six months of Fridays… 24 Fridays. so in UNC time that’s 24.

1 2 3 4

Leave a Reply