Cowher’s Contract? Interim Solution?

Fanblogs.com had a nice comprehensive piece that will interest you.

The entry includes links to Pittsburgh newspapers that highlight Bill Cowher’s contractual status with the Steelers has him committed through next season. The newspapers also suggest that the Rooney family is probably not inclined to allow Cowher out of his contract to coach anywhere next season – including a college job.

Obviously this is just speculation and nobody knows what goes on behind the scenes. But, as much as the last seven years have seen the stars move closer to alignment for the dream of Bill Cowher coaching at NC State, it kind of feels like the stars could still be just one year a away from reaching optimal positioning.

With ^this said, allow me propose a potential solution and throw something out for fun. I realize that this is a stretch, but SFN is a fan site and this is what we do; we talk like fans and come up with fan-like scenarios.

Assumptions
First, we must assume for a moment that the following information and speculation is correct (some of which we KNOW is correct…but just run with it) :

* Consistent with many past public and private statements, Bill Cowher truly would like to end his coaching career as the head football coach of his alma mater, NC State University.

* Bill Cowher really would be willing to trade an NFL salary and job that will pay him north of $6 million per annum in the future for a different challenge on the college level that would pay him approximately $2 million a year.

* The Rooney’s will refuse to release Cowher to coach anywhere other than Pittsburgh in 2007.

* Kay Cowher and Bill Cowher would like to take a year off from coaching (2007) on any level before getting back into the game.

Proposed Solution
IF these three variable are all true AND Bill Cowher would commit to be NC State’s Head Football coach starting in 2008, then why wouldn’t NC State consider an INTERIM HEAD COACH for 2007?

If Cowher truly wants the job and the problem is truly nothing more than logistics, then why wouldn’t NC State consider an INTERIM HEAD COACH for 2007?

Stick with me here and think about this as I propose it.

This solution could achieve almost everything that both sides want. State gets its man AND Coach Cowher gets the job that he has previously indicated he wants while having the year of family time without the Rooney’s having any power over the situation? Aren’t ‘win-win’ scenarios the goal of all great solutions?

* Let’s be clear about one thing — this solution is predicated on public disclosure and knowledge that Coach Cowher would be leading the program in 2008. This public component of the recipe is vital to its potential success. This is not a suggestion that we tell the world that “Coach X” is taking over and then Cowher arrives in 2008. The world must know of the situation so that the assistants can be immediately staffed ‘permanently’ and so that the program can be recruiting to Coach Cowher’s presence and reputation immediately.

Try to think innovatively about this and realize that there may be very plausible solutions staring us in the face. I am going to talk about one coach (Jim Donnan) in this scenario but ask you to recognize that Donnan is simply an example of one of many potential coaches that may fit the proposed solution.

As SFN reported yesterday, Jim Donnan has been making a play at the NC State job. (Also, please don’t read anything into that other than the fact that Donnan has expressed an interest. As far as SFN has heard there is little to no reciprocation of interest from the NC State side)

Additionally, allow me to share a little something more that I find interesting – BEFORE Chuck Amato was fired, I was told by someone connected to a big Georgia booster that Donnan had made reference to this booster of his interest in the NC State job. But, what was most interesting is that Donnan had added a statement that he (paraphrased) “would even do the job on an interim basis if that is what State wanted”.

At the time I heard this I found this unprompted reference to being an interim coach interesting. Considering where we stand today, I find this fascinating.

We all know that IF Bill Cowher was ever going to be named head coach in Raleigh that he would have to bring with him an experienced and highly-qualified COLLEGE staff. The two pieces of the puzzle that are going to be most vital for Cowher will be: (1) an assistant who can help him maneuver the college system and (2) a keen COLLEGE offensive coordinator.

Well…who does that describe? If Jim Donnan would be willing to be the Assistant Head Coach and Offensive Coordinator when Cowher arrives would you NOT want to take this package deal?

NC State fans who love what Paul Johnson did at the Division 1-AA level certainly can’t complain with this idea. Like Johnson, Jim Donnan also won a 1-AA National Championships and 2 Coach of the Year honors while successfully scaring the hell out of Division One teams at Marshall. He also succeeded on a much higher level at Georgia than Johnson has at just Navy. (Donnan was 40-19 overall and 25-15 in the SEC)

In addition to coaching at Florida State, Donnan was the Offensive Coordinator of Oklahoma’s high powered offenses from 1985-1989 when the Sooners won 49 games, including 27 straight Big Eight contests and the 1985 National Championship.

Donnan is currently a part-time ESPN announcer who is not going to get another Head Coaching gig unless he does something else first. Even if he only wants to use the interim job as a stage to get another head job then what harm is there? State would get one of the best head coaches of the 1980s and 1990s on our sideline who is obviously driven to succeed as much as he can with his opportunity. I’ve got no problem with that. If he stays then you get Donnan’s offensive success and knowledge of the college game packaged with Bill Cowher’s Super Bowl trophy and NFL success That ain’t too bad.

Again, remember that these suggestions are designed to be ‘win-win’ for all involved and:

* are obviously based on a situation where Cowher is committed to NC State but the logistics can’t immediately come together

* use Jim Donnan as a specific example that fits the proposed solution. There obviously could be many other coaches that also fit the solution.

Talk to me. Why wouldn’t we do this? Tell me what you think!

General NCS Football

108 Responses to Cowher’s Contract? Interim Solution?

  1. pack7483 11/29/2006 at 9:32 AM #

    Hell yes….why not? Sounds a little far fetched, but I would be in favor.

  2. Mr O 11/29/2006 at 9:32 AM #

    It is an interesting scenario. How likely?

    Jeff: Probably 1%

  3. beowolf 11/29/2006 at 9:35 AM #

    I would support this idea fully.

    Besides, if there’s one thing we NC State fans are good at, it’s saying “Wait Till Next Year.”

    Plus, I imagine there will be a big boost every time Cowher came to visit.

  4. joe 11/29/2006 at 9:35 AM #

    Is it fair to the players to have them play under a coach who they know will only be in charge for 1 year? For the seniors next year that’s a bad deal.

    I would be really suprised if they hired an interim coach.

  5. MTDPack 11/29/2006 at 9:38 AM #

    JB-

    This would be a fantatic solution. It’s just hard for me to comprehend that BC is so burned out on the NFL that he would potentially turn down $8 million per on the open market, to settle for $2 million per at NCSU. If he’s willing to do that, then God will have finally smiled upon us. Lets hope your scenario plays out. Otherwise, bring on PJ!

  6. theTHRILL 11/29/2006 at 9:39 AM #

    Why we won’t do it – “Try to think innovatively about this and realize that there may be very plausible solutions staring us in the face.” I just don’t see our administration doing something that could make this much sense.

  7. NCSUSix 11/29/2006 at 9:39 AM #

    I like this plan. Forward this link to Chuck Neinas and lets see if he can make it happen.

  8. Brikyrd83 11/29/2006 at 9:40 AM #

    Probably the only scenario for getting Cowher. And the fact that the NCSU job was not discussed at his PC yesterday says a lot. Whatever it takes to land him, I hope they do it!!!

  9. xcharbo 11/29/2006 at 9:43 AM #

    Looks good, but remember LF has to think of it… Oh well, good thought while it lasted…

  10. Par Shooter 11/29/2006 at 9:44 AM #

    When was the last time that Donnan functioned as an OC? Did he call plays at Marshall or UGa?

    My only concern with Cowher is that his success will largely be tied to the quality of his OC due to his defensive background. And to be fair, he’s had a few dogs for OC’s at Pittsburgh through the years. I’m afraid that a Cowher-coached team with a Trestman quality OC will still struggle. I’m not saying that Donnan would be anywhere near as bad as Trestman (is that possible?). Just that I wonder how much of a “sure thing” Donnan would be as an OC.

    Now pitch this solution with Norm Chow as interim and it has a really, really nice ring to it.

  11. WV Wolf 11/29/2006 at 9:48 AM #

    One small correction, Bob Pruett was the Marshall head coach when they moved up from 1-AA. Donnan’s last year at Marshall was 95, Pruett came in 96, went undefeated and won the national title, then The Herd moved up to the MAC in 97.

    Jeff: Thanks so much for this. I’ll fix it

  12. drhammondo 11/29/2006 at 9:50 AM #

    I agree with theTHRILL…this is a fun scenario to think about…but it can’t happen without a very savvy administration. Which, we definitely do NOT have.

    The other fun thing about this coaching search being so hush-hush with Neinas at the helm…it allows us time to dream up these situations…instead of conversing exhaustingly over every little leak that comes out of the AD.

  13. RickJ 11/29/2006 at 9:50 AM #

    Very creative idea and it just might work. It is amazing just how much coaching talent there is in the NC State family in both football & basketball.

    There is some irony here – Didn’t Donnan leave after Holtz was hired after serving on the staff with one year interim Coach Al Michaels?

  14. Tired in Florida 11/29/2006 at 9:55 AM #

    ….I think Jimmy could/would run the program and then become OC when Cowher took the program over…..and I think Jimmy would do just that……makes too much sense to me so it probably won’t work out but it sure gets the PMS 186 blood flowing freely to think about it….I assume you sent this to Oblinger……

  15. 98st8 11/29/2006 at 10:03 AM #

    That is an interesting thought… seems unlikely, but has a d1 program ever hired someone on a temporary basis then turned the reigns over to someone else? … and I don’t mean firing a guy midway thru the year and having a guy take over for the remainder.

  16. partialqualifier 11/29/2006 at 10:07 AM #

    My brother actually asked me about this a month ago. He used Norm Chow as OC/Interim Head Coach. He felt like Cowher was a year away and thought this would be a very good option. Chow would have to agree to move over to OC when Cowher got there in 2008. I thought it was rediculous because of the logistics. It would be next to impossible to find the guy who would be willing to do this first of all. Even if you found someone willing…it would have to be someone Cowher could work with when he became coach. It would be a very, very, very short list of potential candidates.

    I think the chances are slim to none….altho I would certainly give this option to Cowher if I were Lee Fowler.

  17. highonlowe 11/29/2006 at 10:10 AM #

    It sounds like a possibility that could certainly satisify all parties. I know that interim coaching arrangements have been used in basketball (Guthridge at UNX I think), but can anyone think of an example in football? An out-of-the-box idea like this is exactly why I’m glad we hired a consultant.

  18. Dexter 11/29/2006 at 10:10 AM #

    Donnan has burned WAY to many bridges with NC State for this to happen…

  19. sautz 11/29/2006 at 10:11 AM #

    Its a fun idea. I don’t even see the need to bring in someone like Donnan unless he really wants to be associate head coach and OC when Cowher arrives. I wouldn’t see a problem with Cowher chosing a staff and letting the OC or DC he picks be interim head coach, even if they don’t have HC experience. One year should not hurt with the promise of Cowher coming in the next year.

  20. jbwbubba 11/29/2006 at 10:14 AM #

    Interesting, but would put the program in the freezer for a year. Would also hurt recruiting, would feel bad for Seniors to be coached by part time guy. Also what if Donnan were to go nuts and win 9 games. Would you then dump him for Cowher? Better chance of getting Cowher out of his contract in Pittsburgh, if that means a buyout, so be it.

  21. Lock 11/29/2006 at 10:16 AM #

    You know, when I first read this, I found the idea abhorrent. I mean, seriously, how piecemeal can you get?

    But as I read, the idea grew on me, especially if it’s true that Donnan would be willing to be the temporary guy. I don’t see it happening, but it’s an interesting idea.

    Though I find it interesting if it’s true that Cowher did not deny any involvement in the NCSU coaching search at his last PC.

  22. harrisek 11/29/2006 at 10:22 AM #

    For some reason this makes me think of Tennessee “interim” head coach Philip Fulmer who stood in while Johnny Majors was dealing with health issues. The interim did such a good job that Major wasn’t welcomed back.

    I’m not saying that would happen in this unlikely scenario, but it could.

  23. Barry Saunders 11/29/2006 at 10:22 AM #

    Sorry, but this idea is idiotic and a recipe for disaster. We need a head coach now. One year of an interim coach could possibly set us back 3 years in recruiting.

  24. ShootingGuard 11/29/2006 at 10:27 AM #

    I think people, especially media types and opposing fans, get too caught up in the money and the pay cut aspect of the BC situation…

    Money has different meanings for different people…

    Some people long for more and more dollars and won’t let go of a dime no matter how many dollars they have…

    Other people, when they are already loaded or have achieved total financial independence, value money differently and seek more qualitative—rather than quantitative—aspects of life…

    Warren Buffett could live in NYC with Trump and have TV shows and make all kinds of extra money doing all kinds of things, but he would rather be in Nebraska, eating simple food, and watching the Big Red…

    Does BC like the NFL $? Sure, but he’s got plenty of it now. Why did BC not take the NCSU job back a few years ago? Probably as much about having not achieved the ultimate goal of winning the Super Bowl as anything else. Will BC take the NCSU job? I have no idea, but $6M won’t keep BC from taking a rest if he and his wife decide that is best for him nor will the difference between $6M and $2M keep him from leading the Pack if it’s in his blood and the competitor in him wants a new challenge after getting that Super Bowl win…

  25. packpigskinfan23 11/29/2006 at 10:28 AM #

    I like this proposal with Chow in place of Donnan… weither Chow becomes an assistant later or not. I dont see Chow stepping down if he takes any kind of HC job however… even if it is known as an interim. IF he would come as an interim I would imagine he would go else-where after.

    if Donnan/Cowher could agree on this I saw GO FOR IT!!! Do they have any connections together or know each other?

    I know one thing- I can see think of no better team than Cowher/Chow…. Cowher is a disciplinarian with heart, fam, and love for the school.
    Chow is an offensive wiz with at least a respect for the school.
    Cowher is one of the best defensive minded coaches in the country(pro and college level)
    Chow is one of the best offensive coaches in the country(proven college, and WOULD be proven in the pros had the Titans picked Lienhart!!! idiots…..)

Leave a Reply