- This topic has 69 replies, 27 voices, and was last updated 8 years, 10 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
Herbert was winning and recruiting at a pretty high clip his last 4-5 years.
Better than his first five years?…yep.
Better than Sid?…absolutely.
Better than this year?…sure.But if Herb had actually been winning and recruiting at a high level, then the Great Herb Debate would have never gotten started.
Herbert was winning and recruiting at a pretty high clip his last 4-5 years.
Better than his first five years?…yep.
Better than Sid?…absolutely.
Better than this year?…sure.But if Herb had actually been winning and recruiting at a high level, then the Great Herb Debate would have never gotten started.
I guess it would define winning. He was winning a ton of ACC games and finishing high. He just was flaming out in the tourney.
His recruiting was good though based on rankings, you cant argue that. In business, and NCAA sports are a business, sometimes you have to part ways. After 10 years it was just time for NCSU and Herb to split. He just wasnt doing or saying the right things for the fan base. I truly think we are at the same point with Gott. We paid him millions and he got us some positive attention but now I think its just time to go each others way. It just happens.
Not sure 46-34 (basically an average of 9-7 in the days of the 16 game ACC slate) qualifies as “a ton”.
But then again, I didn’t know 4-10 was considered average so….WTF do I know?
I disagree that it’s time to part ways with Gott. This year is a flameout, and ultimately his responsibility, of course. But so far it is an outlier. If it becomes a trend, then it’s time to make a move.Not sure 46-34 (basically an average of 9-7 in the days of the 16 game ACC slate) qualifies as “a ton”.
But then again, I didn’t know 4-10 was considered average so….WTF do I know?“ton” may have been the wrong word, but Herb was finishing relatively high in the ACC.
I thought it was time for him to go.
I cannot believe we are debating herbert on the day after the UNC game. That shows the depths of where we are right now.
I guess .500 is now considered an “average” season per this thread. Expectations run high; why, we could even finish above .500 overall with a few upsets before this miserable season has mercifully ended.
I was among the hundreds who headed for the exits last night long before the final seconds ticked off. There were Carolina fans decked out in blue all over the lower bowl, but even they became quiet as the final minutes played out.
This isn’t a rivalry anymore, folks. What we have is two programs that are poles apart, and ours is moving rapidly away from relevance to just plain substandard. It is unimaginable how much worse State would be if Cat Barber’s offense suddenly went south the way Marcus Paige’s has this season. The Heels, even without Paige, are still double-digits better than we are. It may be even worse next year.
I did renew my WPC membership this week, and will for now continue to get basketball season tickets. My football attendance ended last season because I see Wolfpack football as hopeless even in the long run. And there is no logical reason to think that basketball will get any better anytime soon. We have mostly marginally talented players who lack skill sets in the areas of shooting the ball from the 10 to 15-foot range, team defense (especially forcing turnovers), and most basic fundamentals like blocking out and setting screens.
Those who say that things won’t change under this Wolfpack coaching staff and administration are probably right. We have an AD who will likely stick with the status quo for the long haul. It is unimaginable to me why we keep the same people in charge of athletics and coaching, given that we are absolutely among the three worst programs in the ACC in both football and basketball.
The hell of it is, we’re getting worse.
The hell of it is, we’re getting worse.
Granted I am an eternally pessimistic State fan and I always look at the negative. Thats what years of State fail has done to me but I see next year with our new qb and schedule to be a ugly season. The schedule doesnt do us any favors. As to Bball we lose Cat and as you mentioned above holy hell the offense may be beyond putrid if a true frosh pg is supposed to be the savior.
So as to your last comment I totally agree.
FWIW, I understand why people are irked about this year. I am too. I also get why they are pessimistic going forward to next year. I am too.
And Gott’s seat SHOULD be very warm. And he should be made aware of that fact by the PTB.
But there is no question that it should remain his seat for at least one more season IMHO.
But opinions differ, of course. That’s why this place exists.
Yay dissent!!!!!
13Ot: you are at where I am at. I’d suggest taking it a step further and leaving the Wolfpack club and giving up your basketball tickets. The only thing that changes this is money. It will either take a massive influx from someone unhappy with Yow and Gott, or it is the bleeding out from fans canceling out that even she can’t ignore.
The problem with Pack fans is that we’re too good. We keep buying tickets despite lack of performance. We’re sort of like a battered spouse.
In that model, why would anything ever change? The university doesn’t care about butts in seats. They care about gate sales. Some sketchy attendance reporting this year can show you that.
I hate to say it, but as long as the money keeps flowing in, one is edfectively supporting the status quo.
The problem with Pack fans is that we’re too good. We keep buying tickets despite lack of performance. We’re sort of like a battered spouse.
Being male, I always gravitated to the “Cheating/Gold digging gf” analogy. But yours is equally apt. Bravo.
Yay getting in touch with our feminine side (not that hubby’s can’t be battered as well…yay, I just got in touch with my “I’m not sexist side”).Stupidly weighing in on this Sendek / Gott comparison. Sendek inherited a program where the NIT was a huge step up…after a promising start he plateaued. He had a disasterous year 5, but then made 5 consecutive tournaments.
The only reason I held out some hope with Sendek was because this was first major gig, he had good bloodlines, didn’t seem to do much else other than coach basketball, and because he proved a ton of folks wrong when he made the tourney, and I figured it could have been just part of painfully slow progress. (That he had already shown).
Gott, OTOH, was a guy who actually left (or was forced to leave mid season.) His career showed steady progress at Bama, then it fell apart. Either he changed, the game changed or his conference got tougher. When he came here, the hope was and still remains that he knows exactly what went at Bama and won’t let it happen again.
This hear creates doubts that he has. Even in his successful seasons, there have been some glaring red flags that we weren’t building, bit rather simply treading water.
Next year will tell us a ton. Hopefully, after it, we won’t lose our best coaching options if it ends like I expect.
I don’t want Gott fired, he doesn’t deserve it. He has delivered solid results, and has earned next year.
His [Herb’s] recruiting was good though based on rankings, you cant argue that.
But how much do the rankings mean when the big wins don’t follow? Herb cleaned up against the bottom of the conference year after year and struggled against anyone that could be considered “good” (ie RPI Top-50). Teams moved beneath or above State in the conference rankings, but State was pretty consistent in years 5-10 (exception: #2 regular season finish in 2004).
The Great Herb Debate was driven by the issue of using present/past results to predict future performance. In other words, pretty much the same place we are today.
I’d be pissed if I bought season tickets and had high expectations too. Fortunately, I’ve tempered my season expectations 2 or 3 times already this year and gave up making regular, long treks to basketball games years ago.
As for football, I’ve found the key to success (for me anyway). I make my primary focus the tailgate since I may or may not be satisfied with what I see once I walk in the stadium. 🙂
Either way, I love the University and will continue to watch us play all sports, especially when I can enjoy a cold, adult beverage at the same time.
The day started with locking my keys in my car, bad sign, we come out of the gates vs. the holes and gain a 13 point lead, thanks to Barber, nobody else, except for some good play from Abu. Then as Barber goes, so goes the team, and the lead quickly faded. And our bricks kept coming. Game over, then get to my car, only to be stuck in the mud, by the football stadium, but thanks to some nice young men, I was pushed out of that problem. Bad day! Roy has a ridiculous record against us. Why can’t we get top notch recruits. I remember the day when Duke wasn’t the power it is now. We put money in the program and deserve a better outcome. We should be able to have a deep bench of players capable of playing in games. Not just bench warmers.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
