N & O: No-show classes mostly for athletes

Good morning!  The News and Observer has played Santa yet again.  Wait until you get a load of some of the bombshells in Kane’s latest front-page above-the-fold article that hit this morning.

The entire thing is a must-read.  Here are some explosive passages:

Students looking to enroll in a summer class at UNC-Chapel Hill taught by Julius Nyang’oro were likely to hit a roadblock as soon as they went online.

Of the 38 courses the university says he was responsible for over five summers, 26 of them listed a maximum capacity for just one student. For many students, that would be a sign to go look for another course.

But university records show more than one student enrolled in most of these courses. And often, a substantial share of those students were athletes.

and

There’s another wrinkle to all this. Nyang’oro, the former chairman of the African and Afro-American Studies department where all these courses were listed, did not get paid for 29 of these suspect summer classes. Typically, professors are paid per class because the work is considered beyond their normal nine-month work year.

Willis Brooks and Jay Smith, two UNC-CH history professors who are concerned about the case’s impact on the university’s academic integrity, said the enrollment and pay data suggest Nyang’oro had set up a system for athletes to get into classes they could pass.

“The only logic I can conjure is (Nyang’oro) was protecting seats,” said Brooks, a professor emeritus who served on the faculty athletic committee in the early 1990s. “And since the preponderance of people who took the seats are athletes, there is circumstantial evidence,” he said.

and

Current and former UNC-CH officials say they can’t recall a worse case of academic fraud at the university….. The investigation started with a suspicious transcript belonging to a former UNC football player. Top leaders at UNC-CH and the UNC system, however, say athletics weren’t at the heart of the academic fraud, because nonathletes were in the suspect classes, too.

But athletes and former athletes made up a majority of those enrolled in the suspect classes. The university says that athletes and former athletes made up 64 percent of the enrollments.

and

UNC records show that in addition to the courses he taught, Nyang’oro supervised independent studies without pay for another 60 students during those summer semesters; at least 22 were football players. The independent studies are also academically suspect, according to an internal review UNC-CH officials released last month.

The summer courses are among 75 linked to Nyang’oro over a four-year period. University officials said that is an extraordinary number for a professor, let alone a department chairman, to have responsibility for, but no one noticed until the fraud investigation began.

The hooligans over on PackPride have done a fantastic job keeping up with the scandal (and driving it in many cases).  Their instant analysis is often very useful.  This is a post from this morning pointing out the new ground this article breaks:
There is major new info in this article, including info that is new to this board:
– Nyang’oro “taught” many of the classes for free (at least officially)
– The 64% athlete/former athlete figure is new. 24 hours ago, what we knew was (iirc) 54% athlete, unknown % former athlete
– Strong circumstantial evidence exists that the same stuff was happening as long ago as 2001, based on class records
Stay tuned.
UNC Scandal

55 Responses to N & O: No-show classes mostly for athletes

  1. WolftownVA81 07/08/2012 at 5:25 PM #

    MattN, Here’s another twist. I don’t know how the State Government Personnel rules read but in the Federal Government, employees can’t work for free (to keep managers from abusing employees). If the State rules read the same, he must be paid. Once he is paid, then we have a fraud case which is probably what this scheme was designed to avoid.

  2. backnine 07/08/2012 at 5:45 PM #

    Given all this evidence of evildoing, its a no-brainer for the NCAA to return to UNC and conduct a new investigation. But don’t hold your breath waiting for it to happen. I think the NCAA has happily moved on from UNC and never wanted to investigate them in the first place. The NCAA will likely have to be FORCED to go back. And that would mean a smoking gun of intent to deceive and enable athletes is found. Someone will have to spill the beans on record for that to happen.

  3. mrwufabc 07/08/2012 at 6:00 PM #

    So, lets spill it for them. We’re NC State grads. Engineers, farmers, etc. I’m sure we can do more than what is already done.
    For starters, I got the runaround when I tried to file a FOIA request through that institution. Perhaps someone who knows-can enlighten us all with the specifics on how to file a FOIA request against unc. I want to file one in reference to parking tickets in reference to a specific booster. If you know how to do this-please give details.

  4. golf76 07/08/2012 at 9:17 PM #

    “We’re NC State grads. Engineers, farmers, etc.”

    Little known fact — we have journalists as well. Many have graduated in journalism from our Communications Dept. and some work for newspapers, although newspapers are becoming a thing of the past. Google how to file a FOIA request and check out http://www.splc.org/foiletter.asp. Should help.

  5. Pack Mentality 07/08/2012 at 10:09 PM #

    One has to assume that he wasn’t cheating for these athletes, and offering fake courses just because he wanted the football and basketball teams to win. A department head is a top position that educators work their whole lives for and one doesn’t take risks like this recklessly and for no reason. He was either getting paid by the coaches or most likely by some back door Ram’s club channeling.

    And no matter what he got paid for cheating for football and basketball players he would not think that this amount of money would be enough for him as a department head to blatantly do this and risk losing his job.

    This leads one to believe that he had absolutely no fear that he would lose his job. The only plausible reasons for this are that he was directly told by a trusted source that top administrators would turn a blind eye to this when they saw it turning up and there was no danger to his career for this behavior. Or that this was such an accepted and standard practice at the University that there was no need to tell him directly that this kind of blind eye would be turned to these fake classes.

  6. tuckerdorm1983 07/09/2012 at 6:02 AM #

    “No Show Nyang’oro” this is his theme song.

  7. YogiNC 07/09/2012 at 8:38 AM #

    There is something nagging at me that says this is not the only instance of this happening, there were others. SOOOOO, that being said what would be the easiest way to find out what other classes may be in play? Easy, check the transcripts of every football and basketball player over the last oh say 20 years. Look to the courses that had the highest common number of registrations AND the high grades and bingo, we got us a conspiracy of fraud!

  8. primacyone 07/09/2012 at 10:28 AM #

    ***If the class admission was limited to 1 student through normal registration prcedures, then how in the heck did all those atheltes obtain admission to all those “no show classes”….?

    On the surface as it related to said curcumstantial evicdence, there would certainly appear to be some “organized effort” to get those ateletes registed in said calsses. There would be certainly appear to be some orgainzed effort besides just the efforts of Nyang’oro and an athlete…????

    But yet, the brain trust over at UNC has no answers: We didn’t know. It was not our responsbility. It was not adnormal, the entire university was doing it the same way. I didn’t have anything to do with it. This issue is not important. “We don’t have to anwser that”, you need to ask Nyang’oro . .

  9. Hungwolf 07/09/2012 at 11:32 AM #

    Charlotte Observer has now picked up the article, let’s hope it continues to circulate to other media outlets. Has it made its way to TV anywhere yet?

  10. Clarksa 07/09/2012 at 11:55 AM #

    ^The Charlotte Observer and News&Observer and one in the same now…owned by the same company and share reporters.

    I think a good question being asked on Pack Pride is how many student managers/trainers make up the additional 36% of those classes.

  11. ADVENTUROO 07/09/2012 at 12:20 PM #

    Glad this is still a topic. However, I have spent quite a bit of time googling phrases that link Uncle Juius and the Nike Foundation. Most hits are just blog entries. Is there ANY published reports of Julius or his associates (purportedly UNC grads with Athletic Connections) receiving the $500K donation. This seems to be more myth and lore than fact.

    I am NOT saying it did not happen, but it has been in the comments of so many articles that it appears to be FACT, but can not be verified.

    Thanks,

  12. wolfbuff 07/09/2012 at 1:09 PM #

    What I would like to know is exactly what the hell does the Dean of Summer School do? She indicated she neither directs that certain classes be offered nor approves which ones are. Seems to me the professors over there (and maybe every where) just do whatever they want and get paid for it with no oversight. Why does there need to be a dean just for summer school?

    This just lends more credence to YogiNC’s assertion above that this cannot be the only class where this has happened in Cheaterville. Where there is smoke there is most definitely fire. The administration is over there beating the flames down as hard as they can. Summer school is definitely a good way to take some classes in order to accelerate a degree timeline. But there should be someone analyzing data on degree programs, orchestrating which courses get offered, and providing oversight to the registration, curriculum, and grading.

    But it also speaks to the waste that they supposedly cannot get rid of. There is so much fat in these universities it’s ridiculous. Give me a month, and I could weed out enough to balance the budget and reduce, yes reduce, tuition.

  13. Hungwolf 07/09/2012 at 1:32 PM #

    I know N&O and Charlotte Observer owned by same company and share reporters, but not all the articles that have appeared in the N&O have been in the Charlotte paper. They don’t run all the same articles in both papers. If anyone sees anything on this in other papers, ESPN, or TV please post. Thanks in advance!

  14. ncsu1987 07/09/2012 at 2:19 PM #

    Would LOVE to see this on ESPN, but not holding my breath. Come on, Mr. Skipper, get in front of this and lead. Or are you just a hopeless homer?

  15. packfanatic 07/09/2012 at 2:24 PM #

    It’s interesting that there is NO mention of this on the unc board. Have they been censored on this topic?

  16. gumby 07/09/2012 at 2:28 PM #

    I propose they rename the school “Devry University at Chapel Hill”

  17. Gene 07/09/2012 at 4:52 PM #

    What do you have against Devry, gumby, to insult Devry like that?

  18. WolftownVA81 07/09/2012 at 5:26 PM #

    ^Agree, that was harsh. I wouldn’t compare UNC to any school unless it was one that got hammered by sanctions for cheating so bad.

  19. Wolf74 07/09/2012 at 7:05 PM #

    You would think that by now an ADULT would step forward over there and try to salvage their rapidly sinking academic reputation by going ahead and admitting to setting up classes for athletes but explaining how they protected the general student population as best they could. Perhaps this and putting their athletics teams on a self mandated probation for 2 years and self forfeiting one or both of the “bought” National Championships would go a long way to stopping the erosion of their general reputation.

    It might even restore some integrity to that institution and their administration, BOT, and the BOG – which presently have NONE!

  20. state73 07/09/2012 at 8:43 PM #

    The leadership in Chapel Hill has no clue to the meaning of integrity. Without a doubt the most corrupt public university in the country!!

  21. tuckerdorm1983 07/09/2012 at 9:26 PM #

    Let me tell you what is NOT being focused upon. The athletic dept has advising for its athletes. They were putting this guys in those classes. Do you think Marvin Austin, who was taking remedial reading, decided on his own to take a graduate level Swahili class? Who was pushing these students into the classes. Who knew of the sweetheart deal with the professor? How far up in the chain of command in the athletic academic advising staff did knowledge of what was going on extend? Should someone not get suspicious about these athletes taking these courses and getting good grades. Are theses advisers shopping for the professors that give athletes a break? Did the coaching staff at the basketball and football level know? I think we all deserve answers. Sure the professor was bad, but you know these kids aren’t going through the course directories and picking out Astrophysics, Advanced French Grammar, Metaphysics and Epistemology, Organic Chemistry and finally upper level Swahili. I think if you dig further you will find a rat!!!!! Get to diggin!!!!

  22. runwiththepack 07/09/2012 at 10:17 PM #

    The lack of uproar over this is incredible. Sure, their rivals (or NON-rivals, if you will), are lathered up. I checked on most other ACC fan message boards and nearly all of them have posted about this. Hopefully the NCAA is taking action, but they just haven’t been heard from yet.

    But that doesn’t explain ESPN’s boredom with this, or Sports Illustrated.

    Occasionally we hear of a kid receiving a $50,000 car and it’s smeared all over the sports news. Right?

    Here, though, we have a $50,000,000 department at a major university that has been used to improperly keep HUNDREDS of athletes eligible for at least TEN YEARS. Probably TWENTY YEARS or more. They obviously got comfortable in their “routine”.

    I guess that’s the kind of good will you generate when you’re squeeky clean.

  23. SqlWolf 07/10/2012 at 6:53 AM #

    I just keep thinking about SMU and the death penalty it received.
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southern_Methodist_University_football_scandal

  24. tractor57 07/10/2012 at 10:01 AM #

    SMU – Chapel Hill branch

  25. triadwolf 07/10/2012 at 11:44 AM #

    If these classes are indeed determined to be fraudulent; does the NCAA then go back and adjust the APR for UNC athletes? If so they could be looking at a similar situation as UConn (or worse).

    What’s worse; not graduating your players or fraudulently graduating players? I would argue the latter…

Leave a Reply