Judge rules against McAdoo

Full WRAL story. 

Judge Orlando Hudson needed just a little over two hours to come to his conclusion in a Durham courtroom denying an injunction and thus preventing McAdoo’s return to the field.

“Mr. McAdoo committed academic fraud. He is a cheater. That is what happened here,” Sun said. “The university makes the eligibility decision and that is what they did. They ruled him ineligible.

“The NCAA takes academic fraud very seriously. The university’s facts presented to NCAA show academic fraud. Presumption is (that) there should be ineligibility.”

Sun further went on an a personal attack of McAdoo saying, “McAdoo can’t meet regular standards of a student, much less higher standards expected for an exception.”

Stephanie Brennan of the Attorney General’s office and representing UNC drew up an argument of the university following due procedure.

“The University has said and continues to believe that the penalty imposed was to harsh, but university lost the appeal and respects decision,” Brennan said. “We are simply not in a position where we can declare a player unilaterally eligible.”

 

Also, WTVD’s Mark Armstrong’s Twitter feed is a good place to find breaking news related to the scandals.

 

General UNC Scandal

37 Responses to Judge rules against McAdoo

  1. wufpup76 07/14/2011 at 1:08 AM #

    We <3 Marv.

    And remember everyone, when things get tough you need to use that time-tested truism: BLAME STATE FANS. What's good for the goose …

  2. Wolfsrudel 07/14/2011 at 3:19 AM #

    If the football program is this dirty, then I wonder what goes on with the basketball program. I also wish that a Tarhole knew when to use “there” or “their” in a sentence.

  3. JeremyH 07/14/2011 at 4:05 AM #

    “anchormanaustin marvin austin
    And stop the cowardly acts when the are in front of the ncaa just tell them what you told us…don’t turn and twist your story to look
    32 minutes ago”

    that’s quite interesting

  4. 1.21 Jigawatts 07/14/2011 at 6:41 AM #

    From the N&O article:

    “An affidavit filed Wednesday by UNC associate athletic director for compliance Amy Herman indicated that the university was willing to keep McAdoo on scholarship and offer him a position as a student coach for the 2011 season. Huffstetler said that offer “hasn’t been emphasized” in previous discussions with the school.”

    They want to continue paying the education of a major cheater PLUS employee him on the same football team he was ruled ineligible to play on because of accepting gifts and cheating in class. WOW. They just never learn do they.

  5. nav 07/14/2011 at 6:58 AM #

    “They want to continue paying the education of a major cheater PLUS employee him on the same football team he was ruled ineligible to play on because of accepting gifts and cheating in class. WOW. They just never learn do they.”

    It’s called hush money.

  6. sequoyah 07/14/2011 at 7:26 AM #

    All those tweets make you wonder if Marvin’s not the braintrust (and $) behind this lawsuit. Who else could hatch such a misguided legal action?

  7. lush 07/14/2011 at 7:45 AM #

    Wolfsrudel:

    Not just the athletes. I have a family friend with a signed helmet that says “John, your awesome. Thanks for all you do. Butch Davis”

    Priceless

  8. highstick 07/14/2011 at 8:32 AM #

    Is there a precedent for a student coach without a degree? Or is this just more extra benefits?

  9. ppack3 07/14/2011 at 8:49 AM #

    Let’s see if I have the time line correct. McAdoodle cheats multiple times and accepts illegal benefits, gets caught, UNC Honor Court says he’s guilty, UNC asks the NCAA if a hypothetical situation like McAdoodle’s is punishment worthy, only then does UNC actually admit (er, self-report) McAdoodle in conjunction with the other violations, the NCAA rules him ineligible, UNC then appeals the punishment and after it is denied by the NCAA McAdoodle sues the University and the NCAA for unquantifiable punitive damages and immediate reinstatement to the Football team.

    So, at that point, Bad-doer offers the kid a job and an academic scholarship!? WTF is going on here? Is anyone asking the easy questions? WTF?! WTF?!

  10. whitefang 07/14/2011 at 10:54 AM #

    I just can’t believe that the NCAA won’t slam UNC with maximum penalties. Contrast UNC to Ohio State and other schools under the gun over the years whose leadership took the stand that they are going to institute their own sanctions and clean up their programs for the integrity of the academic institution (that is after all what these are SUPPOSED to be). Instead UNC is so obviously covering up at ever step. The NCAA HAS to make an example of them. If they don’t the NCAA will have lost whatever integrity they had.

  11. camel77 07/14/2011 at 12:55 PM #

    nav and highstick

    I think the scholarship is the only thing he will get. Something similar like this has happen before with a player getting hurt and can’t play anymore but has a year or so lefted on his scholarship time. This is just a way for him to get his degree.

  12. highstick 07/14/2011 at 7:11 PM #

    I’ve got no problem with him getting his degree………..AS LONG AS HE IS NOT CHEATING WITH UNIVERSITY ASSISTANCE TO GET IT!!!

    Nor should he be furnished a tutor of any sort!

Leave a Reply