UNC scandal blows up overnight; Board of Governors prepared to step in

 

It should be a very busy morning in light of the story that broke last night detailing extensive communication via cell phone and text messages between former UNC coach John Blake and sports agent Gary Wichard. Since this story broke, ABCers have been waiting for the local media to make a break in this story and give it the amount of coverage many people feel the scandal in Chapel Hill deserves. Of course, the local media still has yet to make a call for a truly independent investigation of the UNC athletic department despite obvious conflicts of interest the local media has pointed out (even if it was late in the course of the investigation).

Still, this flood of stories and columns may represent a turn in the UNC scandal. Yesterday, one national media pundit called for Butch’s job. Now the local media has discovered questionable conduct by a football coach and a potential lack of institutional controls both in the hiring processes at UNC and the monitoring of staff member activities. Of course, we have already detailed a possible lack of institutional controls on social networking site issues extensively despite UNC’s vast experience with the problems participation on these sites can create and a working knowledge of student-athlete rights to participate versus the need for institutional control.

Updated(8:21 am)

Link to Daily Tarheel:

Hannah Gage, the chairwoman of the UNC System Board of Governors, says the board is prepared to step in if UNC-Chapel Hill administrators are unable to handle the ongoing investigations into the Tar Heel football program.

In a letter to the board, UNC-system President Erskine Bowles said Thorp, Baddour, UNC-CH football coach Butch Davis and an investigative team were working together to get all of the facts.

“The University, under the leadership of our chancellor, will continue to investigate this matter and to take appropriate action until we are sure we have gotten to the bottom of this and done everything possible to make sure it never happens again,” Bowles said in the letter.

 

Oh!  So NOW it is an investigation!?  Good to know!  When did it move from “review” to “investigation,” just so we will know?

Important note: Hannah Gage is a 1975 graduate of UNC. Thorp is 1986 graduate of UNC and longtime UNC employee. Baddour began his career at UNC in 1967. And of course, Bowles is also a UNC graduate.

Butch’s hiring process of Blake in question:

Davis has known him since Blake was a student at Sand Springs High in Oklahoma in the late 1970s. Davis was an assistant coach and a biology teacher at Sand Springs. Davis and Blake, 49, also coached together with the Dallas Cowboys in 1993 and 1994.

“You have to put it into context: I coached John Blake for two years in high school,” Davis said. “Then there was at least a 12-year period of time when I didn’t see him until he was minority intern to the Dallas Cowboys for one summer and then came back the following year for two years as defensive line coach. Then when I went to Miami, from 1995 until here, another 12 years, between our relationship.”

Butch expects to finish 2010 season:

Two days after his top assistant abruptly resigned as the NCAA continues to investigate his program, North Carolina football coach Butch Davis renewed his commitment to the program.

Asked Tuesday if he believes he will be the Tar Heels coach for the rest of the 2010 season, Davis said, “I do. Absolutely.”

Full link to column from Tom Sorenson here.


For decades the Tar Heels have claimed the high moral ground, big-time football’s dirt and grime never rubbing against the hem of their freshly pressed khaki pants.

So what if they failed to compete for national football championships? At least they didn’t cheat. Therefore North Carolina was entitled to make fun of Florida State and the SEC and everybody else accused of winning the wrong way.

No more. The Tar Heels have forfeited, for years if not for decades, the right to condescend.

The next time people complain about an out-of-control program in which rules are little more than a mild suggestion, they probably are talking about North Carolina.

Column from Caulton Tudor:

Blake’s possible role in the probe related to improper player contacts with agents hardly was sorted out, either.

That aspect of the situation actually became more confusing when Raleigh lawyer and former UNC player Wade Smith, who has been assisting the coach, would not answer question about whether Blake was taking money from agents while working as a college coach.

“That’s a complicated question. I should not deal with that … while the investigations are ongoing,” Smith said.

At the highest levels of college football competition, lots of coaches double as independent businessmen.

In that context, it’s only natural that Blake and his lawyer or lawyers did their best to arrange the best-possible exit package.

But it was a strange development in a progressively strange story that apparently isn’t likely to reach a quick conclusion. It’s almost unheard of for a healthy coach to quit only one game into a season, much less one of the most important seasons in the school’s history.

UNC Scandal

69 Responses to UNC scandal blows up overnight; Board of Governors prepared to step in

  1. Wufpacker 09/08/2010 at 6:37 AM #

    So, as usual it comes down to: Who knew what, and when did they know it?

    These guys (Blake and Wichard) might very well be friends and their friendship may very well pre-date any business issues or relationships. But these were NOT personal calls….these were business calls as sure as shi’ite.

    As if these phone records weren’t enough to show a pre-existing BUSINESS relationship, there are two things that make this situation even more obvious, AND more damning for Butchy. Those things are….

    1) The pamphlet that listed Blake as being/having been employed by Wichard’s company.

    AND….

    2) Butch’s deny, deny, deny attitude so far, as illustrated by the quote below:

    ” In the article Butch Davis is quoted explaining that he had no idea as to the frequency of Blake’s communications with Wichard — ‘I didn’t know that he was talking to him that frequently. I didn’t know if he was talking to him once a year, twice a month. I had no idea.’ ”

    The difference between the two possible scenarios (Butch is a cheater vs. Butch knew nothing ) is huge, by the way. The difference is that in one scenario Butch is professional toast (maybe even in the NFL). In the other, UNC’s football program (possibly their entire athletics dept.) is NCAA toast.

    So the question boils down to how much is Butch willing to sacrifice his own future professional well-being, his own “employability” as it were, in order to give UNC plausible deniability? Or, said from a slightly different if more cynical point of view….

    How much is UNC willing to PAY Butch to throw HIMSELF under the bus, rather than the university?

  2. wufpup76 09/08/2010 at 7:01 AM #

    Don’t ask, don’t tell …

  3. Texpack 09/08/2010 at 7:14 AM #

    Can a UNC-CH fan exist without condescending? I think not.

  4. PacknSack 09/08/2010 at 7:48 AM #

    Plausible Deniability. I’m willing to bet Butch’s marching orders to Blake were “do what you gotta do, just don’t tell me” — which has been SOP over there for more than three decades.

  5. TOBtime 09/08/2010 at 7:56 AM #

    In my profession, as in most I can think of, you get fired for being stupid (unaware) or cheating (embezzlement, price fixing, etc.) so I’m wondering what difference does it make which one BMFD is? In light of the news that broke last night he must be both. Knowledge of a murder makes you an accomplice whether you actively participate or not.

    It just gets better and better!

  6. Wufpacker 09/08/2010 at 7:56 AM #

    “It’s almost unheard of for a healthy coach to quit only one game into a season, much less one of the most important seasons in the school’s history.”

    Why, exactly, does Tudor think this is one of the most important seasons in their football history?

    Maybe before all of this broke. Maybe. But now, I would think they all just want to forget, and will really want to forget when punishments start hitting home and any wins (this season and last 2 as well) start getting vacated.

    I guess it could be one of the most important in and SMU-like capacity.

  7. Wufpacker 09/08/2010 at 8:03 AM #

    ^^ I don’t think it does matter for Butch himself, at least not as far as his current position is concerned. I think he’s gone either way. If he admits to full knowledge before the fact, however, I think he’ll have a hard time even getting an NFL assistant gig.

    But for Carolina’s overall situation, I think it’s a huge issue. If they can convince Butch to spill his own guts, admit to his own cheating and the knowledge of the other stuff (Blake, academics, etc.), AND insulate Baddour or any of the rest of the athletic dept…..Carolina COULD get out of this pretty lightly relatively speaking.

    The question is, how much will it cost them? He’s not gonna do it for free I don’t imagine.

  8. GAWolf 09/08/2010 at 8:05 AM #

    I like this guy over at IC, as some self-depreciating humor always gives me a good impression of an individual and seems to me he’s aware of what reality is over there:

    * TarheelPolo
    * Recruit
    * 34 posts this site
    * Send Private Message

    Posted: Yesterday 10:41 PM
    RE: Here’s “The Big Story” from N&O
    With all the short calls maybe they can invoke the butt call defense. Blake better learn to lock his phone before he sticks it in his back pocket.

    //////////////////////////////////////////////

    He also had this to say last night:

    TarheelPolo wrote:

    Say what you want. I got a call from a friend on the N&O editing staff just after 10pm. I was asked not to say anything until the article posted and he assumed it would post sometime before 10:30. He told me a little of the info. He also mentioned some things not in the article that makes me more concerned about the depth and pervasiveness of some of the issues.

    They have more at the N&O and if they have it then the NCAA already has it or will get it. Also, because of the agent thing this may get prosecuted by the AG before it is over. When people have to testify under oath things can get out of hand quickly. Any of you that continue to deny where this thing might be headed are just blindly following your hearts and not your minds. We were all distracted by the academic stuff and possibly assumed the agent issues were behind us but that appears not to be the case.

    ////////////////////////////////////////////

    This is interesting because as a friend of mine messaged me last night, the N&O’s typical MO is to write small pieces leading up to an all-encompassing editorial. TarheelPolo’s statement from an alleged insider at the N&O also points this out. It would make sense that there’s more information available to the N&O and if they string it out in smaller segments they can sell more papers and drive more hits to their website. That’s just smart business, and it certainly points to more to come I would think.

  9. Wufpacker 09/08/2010 at 8:23 AM #

    From the Charlotte Observer article:

    “At least they didn’t cheat. Therefore North Carolina was entitled to make fun of Florida State and the SEC and everybody else accused of winning the wrong way.”

    OR, written more for reality than fantasy, it becomes….

    “At least they didn’t get caught cheating. Therefore North Carolina fans thought their teams were clean and therefore felt an unearned sense of entitlement to look down their noses at any other program and/or school and accuse everybody else of cheating, especially when their own teams lost to another school unexpectedly.”

  10. RegularExpression 09/08/2010 at 8:40 AM #

    Charles Robinson from Yahoo sports was on with Adam Gold last night. He said that he has it on good authority that Butch was trying to get rid of Blake during the last off season. Trying to find him a head coaching job or assistant coaching job somewhere else.

    No way Butch would try to get rid of his good friend and best recruiter unless he knew he was dirty. It’s only a question of when for BMFD now. He’s gone, and if I had to bet it will be before the end of this year. The problem for UNC will be finding someone unsoiled by this scandal to take over.

  11. coach13 09/08/2010 at 8:41 AM #

    IMHO the fact that someone has not stepped in and cleaned house makes me think so many people are dirty they don’t know where to begin.

    Honestly, who at UNX is still thinking this is gonna be a magic season? That thaere is something to salvage? At best this team is gonna win 7-8 games. That’s not alot of magic. That’s fair, but not magical?

    So why is everyone being so candid? Why can’t they cut ties with the troubled players/coaches? I think as showed vs LSU that the remaining palyers will do fine. WHY CAN”T THIS UNIVERSITY CUT TIES MOVE ON? What are they waiting for/hiding???

  12. Phang 09/08/2010 at 8:51 AM #

    @RE “He said that he has it on good authority that Butch was trying to get rid of Blake during the last off season. Trying to find him a head coaching job or assistant coaching job somewhere else.”

    and I guess he couldn’t fire Blake for fear of what he’s say.

  13. coach13 09/08/2010 at 8:59 AM #

    I think Butch will be there til end of reg season…he will resign immediately after the last game. He will state “while I have done nothing wrong, I feel I did not do well keeping other people from doing things wrong and thus let you down”. He will sit out 1 year and get a head coaching job elsewhere after that.

  14. StateFans 09/08/2010 at 9:06 AM #

    Was Butch also trying to get rid of all of those talented players that Blake brought in when we was allegedly trying to get rid of Blake? Love the hypocrisy!

    Speaking of hypocrisy…So…NOW Erskine Bowles and the folks at UNC suddenly posture their work as an ‘investigation’ despite the fact that they haven’t had the integrity to recognize & categorize it as anything other than a ‘review’.

    So…which is it? Is it a little ‘review’? Or is it a full scale investigation?

  15. PackisRolling 09/08/2010 at 9:17 AM #

    UNC seems to be pulling out all the stops to protect their reputation and refuse to take any step that might show that one of the Carolina Family made a mistake. While Butch isn’t one of them…they DID hire him so firing him would show admission of guilt. This whole thing is fascinating.

  16. ppack3 09/08/2010 at 9:26 AM #

    “Charles Robinson from Yahoo sports was on with Adam Gold last night. He said that he has it on good authority that Butch was trying to get rid of Blake during the last off season. Trying to find him a head coaching job or assistant coaching job somewhere else.”

    Soooooo, there were no takers, on Blake? How many organizations did Butch shop Blake to? What reasons could he have given for trying to pawn off his Associate Head Coach, Defensive Line Coach and Head Recruiting Coordinator? “Uh, we really don’t need him. Uh, I’m good. Do you want him? He’s got really good connections…”

  17. 93Pack 09/08/2010 at 9:40 AM #

    @RE “He said that he has it on good authority that Butch was trying to get rid of Blake during the last off season. Trying to find him a head coaching job or assistant coaching job somewhere else.”

    Maybe Butch knew something and told Blake he would be gone after this season, and Blake’s backup plan (if he couldn’t get a coaching job) would be to work for Wichard and recuit these UNC players. He could have resigned at the end of the season and then start working for his friend Wichard. The players could then say they decided to go to the agent with their old favorite coach.

  18. Alpha Wolf 09/08/2010 at 9:40 AM #

    UNC seems to be pulling out all the stops to protect their reputation and refuse to take any step that might show that one of the Carolina Family made a mistake.

    This is a dangerous game for them, because the NCAA is going to expect them to fall on their own sword. If they don’t, they stick it in for them, and it will cut much deeper and will take far longer to recover from.

    They may well be trying to make Blake their scapegoat, but Blake’s mistake was using state-owned equipment for his illicit activities. That means the records are prone to sunshine laws and are defacto public record. That in mind, enough of the whole story is coming to light where Blake’s activities are in the public eye that the question begs legitimately: why weren’t the proper controls in place, and if they were, why weren’t they enforced.

    That in and of itself brings the dreaded phrase from a non-partisan point of view: lack of institutional control.

    We are entering a phase I think where NCAA probation is inevitable.

  19. Pack05 09/08/2010 at 9:42 AM #

    from source and he has been on the money the whole way:

    I am telling you people that UNC football is done. Davis may be gone before the GT game. Thier will be no sweeping this under the rug. BMFD can play the ” I never knew card all he wants” He is *** deep in this.
    And for all the IC fans who doubt me who has been right on this and who has been wrong. Your insiders don’t know ****. They know what the football staff knows which is nothing . And things are coming that Baddour, Thorp and Davis have no idea about that will tear your program to the ground.
    Oh and please try and schedule another kick-off classic game for next year because after the fire smolders out you will not be lucky to get a game scheduled with the NC school of the Deaf.

  20. Old MacDonald 09/08/2010 at 9:46 AM #

    “UNC seems to be pulling out all the stops to protect their reputation and refuse to take any step that might show that one of the Carolina Family made a mistake.”

    We are WAY past the point where this is even remotely possible. The “protect their reputation” game is O-V-E-R. So I hope this is where they keep their focus!

  21. Alpha Wolf 09/08/2010 at 9:47 AM #

    ^ Kick-Off Classic?

    They may not be allowed to be on TV… 😀

    Thing is, that’s something that will punish the likes of our fans as well as other fanbases.

  22. Daily Update 09/08/2010 at 9:50 AM #

    Pack 05: That is from Brakk on packpride. He has been right about most everything so far.

  23. old13 09/08/2010 at 9:53 AM #

    ^ WaffleIron has been posting some pretty reliable info on PP as well.

  24. Scooter 09/08/2010 at 9:55 AM #

    We will find out just how effective this investigation will be now that Blake has departed. The investigation should now directly progress to determining what Butch Davis’ involvement and knowledge of these activites has been. Chief has held fast with a plausible deniability line so far, but we’ll see if the NCAA/SOS/or otherwise begin trying to determine what level of constructive knowledge he may have had. If this investigation doesn’t attempt to close the corruption loop, they might as well stop today.

  25. Old MacDonald 09/08/2010 at 10:01 AM #

    Nobody who is honest thinks his deniability is plausible.

Leave a Reply