Top 10 College Basketball Coaches

In mid-October, we blogged this entry related to Stewart Mandel’s list of The Best and The Worst College Football coaches.

Today, Mandel shares his Top 10 active college basketball coaches.

Mandel qualifies his rankings as follows:

Much like I’ve done the past two seasons for football, the following list is an attempt to rank the sport’s top-10 coaches right now. It is not a career-achievement list, so while a coach’s track record obviously plays a huge part in his reputation, more weight was placed on his most recent performances (sorry, Lute Olson). Similarly, only those who have been head coaches for at least three seasons were considered (sorry, Anthony Grant).

As for the criteria, winning championships and getting to Final Fours is the benchmark by which all college coaches are judged. But I also placed added value on coaches who get more out of less, have recently rebuilt programs or whose imprint is clearly visible in the way their teams play.

We were working on this entry when I saw that ACCNow had already made some comments.

Kudos to ACCNow for recognizing:

Like Pete Carroll in football, recent success trumps career achievement on Mandel’s list. He went with, surprise!, Billy Donovan at No. 1.

Ol’ Roy before K? Jim Calhoun in front of K? Hmmm. Don’t necessarily agree but it’s Mandel’s world.

About StateFans

'StateFansNation' is the shared profile used by any/all of the dozen or so authors that contribute to the blog. You may not always agree with us, but you will have little doubt about where we stand on most issues. Please follow us on Twitter and FaceBook

General NCS Basketball Rankings & Lists

34 Responses to Top 10 College Basketball Coaches

  1. xphoenix87 04/12/2007 at 10:40 AM #

    No, he doesn’t say the cutoff is two years, he says he’s listing the best coaches for right now, as in “if you could pick one coach to come to your program, who would it be?” Now, that’s a column that actually has potential, but instead of saying something worthwhile with it, he just spits out a list of big name guys. I can see having Coach K in the top 5, but Calhoun even being on the list is a stretch. He was never K’s equal as a coach, his team last year had no disciple, and his then pulled one of the all-time great botch jobs in tournament history by losing to George Mason despite being the most talented team in the field. For me, if I’m looking at a coach to bring in to a program right now, the top 3 is Donovan, Howland and Williams, and it’s not even close.

    What would be amusing would be to see someone make a list of the top 10 in-game coaches, because a lot of the guys on this list are really poor X-and-O guys, but they recruit really well.

  2. brickman 04/12/2007 at 12:41 PM #

    leave roy boy right where he is . not a .great in game coach . kind of showed it this year . talent does not always win games . we seen it first hand last year .hate to bring it up . but we did.

  3. noah 04/12/2007 at 1:58 PM #

    I hate to rush to the defense of a Carolina coach…but I think it’s absurd for a “top five list” of coaches in the country not to include both K and Roy Williams. I hate Dook and UNC with everything that I’ve got…but those guys are two fo the best coaches of all time…let alone current and active.

  4. ToddKeune 04/12/2007 at 2:03 PM #

    ^that ads to the enjoyment we’ll get from spanking them next several years

  5. Cedarblockhead 04/12/2007 at 2:54 PM #

    It seems all the great ones have in-game troubles. K, Roy and Herb all had these issues. It was their great recruiting that made them so great.

  6. Jimmy V 04/12/2007 at 4:43 PM #

    I’d have to agree with about his first seven, maybe eight. There are different ways to measure the best coaches: lifetime career achievement, last five years, last ten years, conference titles, national titles, Final Fours, NCAA wins, AP top 25 rankings. I think you have to look at the last five to seven years.

    I would rank them as follows:

    1. Donovan. Hottest coach in the country. Only one of two coaches in the last 30 years to repeat as national champions. Has won two national titles at a school with probably more interest in football.

    2. Roy Williams. His last Kansas team almost won the national title. His Carolina team won it in ’05. He is poised to have very, very good Carolina teams in the near future. He has done a great job in recruiting at UNC over the last few years.

    3. Number three is hard to call. I would go with Coach K. He’s won three national titles, numerous ACC titles, been to many Final Fours. Duke is not the juggernaut they were though. Roy has reclaimed Carolina’s place after Gutheridge and Doherty. Sid has State fans the most excited since probably about ’97. Coach K is still very good, but it will be interesting to see if he can lead Duke to another Final Four or national title. Even if he never does, what he has accomplished will stand above many of his peers forever.

    4. Calhoun. He has won two national titles in the last ten years. Very good coach. UConn is probably the premier program in the Northeast.

    5. Izzo or Pitino. This can go either way. I’d probably go Pitino because he won one national title at Kentucky and he set up Tubby’s title the year after he left. Also got Providence to a Final Four. A great feat there.

    6. Izzo. Solid coach. The most accomplished coach in the Big Ten at the moment. One national title and another Final Four. Or is it two Final Fours?

    7. Gary Williams. I know the last few years have been down for Maryland. But I think he has to be in at least the Top 10-12 coaches in the country. Question is: Can Maryland have another big season? They had two big ones some years ago, going to a Final Four one year and winning a national title another. I’m not convinced Maryland will have another big year in the near future.

    8. Ben Howland. Howland has done well at UCLA. Two Final Fours is not bad. I’m sure diehard, demanding Bruin fans are ready for a national title, but I think Howland will get that in the future at some point.

    9. John Calipari. Cal is a good coach. If I would have had to choose between Barnes and him last year, I would have gone with John Calipari. I don’t know that he’s a stable coach. I mean he seems he’s always got his eye on somewhere else. Nothing wrong with listening to other offers, but most people want some degree of loyalty. He built UMass into something special and they really haven’t been heard from lately. He’s built Memphis into a very good team: close to a Final Four the last few years. I think he could have been successful at NC State. He backed down from the challenge though. No bitterness here and I don’t mean this negatively, but I hope we don’t offer Barnes and Calipari ever again.

    10. Jim Boeheim. Syracuse has had some great years, but hasn’t been heard from lately.

    Honorable Mention, in no particular order: Thad Matta, Kelvin Sampson, Rick Barnes, John Beilein, Lute Olson, Tubby Smith, Bill Self, Billy Gillispie. There are a few others who deserve mentioning, too. Now if it’s career achievement, B. Knight has to be in the top two or three, IMO.

  7. brickman 04/12/2007 at 11:56 PM #

    noah ‘ almost dose not count in bball . when at kansas the teams are not as good as acc . when he has a run like k has had in the acc and in ncaa then will give him some props .but to put him up there with the likes of knight ,wooden,and dummy dean ,and rat fase k ,and rupp from kentucky,why do you think could not win at kansas ncaa championship competition was harder than what he played in conf. you are called a coach not only for recruiting but what you do in game to. so to say he is one of best of all time is not only joke it is an insult to the other coachs

  8. tcthdi-tgsf-twhwtnc 04/13/2007 at 11:42 AM #

    “Roy Williams. His last Kansas team almost won the national title. His Carolina team won it in ‘05.”

    I think Ol’ Roy deserves to be on the list but remember he has yet to win a Championship with his players. The * should go beside his name as with other coaches to win with the previous coaches players. Not to mention the fact that Coach D’oh had one of the best recruiting classes in the history of college ball. A class that almost any coach in the country could of won a championship.

  9. BoKnowsNCS71 04/13/2007 at 3:32 PM #

    If not considering character or their past beyond the past 3 to 5 years. Who would you all rate the 10 10 up an comers? Bruce Pearl? for example?

Leave a Reply